As this site is about girls comics clearly Tammy & Jinty special is one I’ve been eagerly awaiting. I was pleased with last year’s issue and this year takes a different approach but is still a joy to read.
This year there are just 2 new complete stories and 1 reprint of the first episode of Ping-Pong Paula (compared to last year’s 9 short stories). This approach certainly has the advantage of giving the stories more time to breathe, although I was little disappointed not to see some returns from last year like Justice of Justine or Bella of the Bar. Personal preference would maybe have split the difference and have 3-4 new stories, so could still have longer stories but bit more variety. Still the stories here are a great read and I wouldn’t be opposed to seeing more retro strips occasionally too. Starting off we have Boarding School (by Rachael Smith and Yishan Li) where a girl, Tabatha and her brother, Richard are the only students at a mysterious boarding school with 4 governesses. While they all fawn over Richard, Tabatha is pretty much ignored, because of this while exploring she meets a girl from outside the school and after talking with her, Tabatha begins to question the motives of the governesses and what are they hiding. I won’t give too much away, but this was an intriguing mystery story, with strong sibling bond and a good villain.
In Cat Girl Returns (by Ramzee and Elkys Nova) we meet the original Cat Girl, Cathy, all grown up and still tracking down bad guys though now as police officer, not as a costumed hero. Meanwhile her daughter Claire is trying to find a costume for a party and comes across her mother’s old cat girl outfit. While at the party Claire begins to notice some strange things, like she now has enhanced senses, and when a social media star gets taken by some criminal she is on hand to help. I like that we get to see Cathy work her case and how it connects to Claire’s heroics. While I’ve liked Rebellions update on characters, it was very fun to see continuation of the Cat Girl story rather than a straightforward reboot. DCT digital Spellbound reprint (which unfortunately was only available for short period before being pulled) had a similar idea where after reprint of I Don’t want to Be a Witch” there was a short story focusing on Celia’s daughter. It is nice to see these legacy characters as we get a new updated character but also get to see what the older character grew up to become. It probably wouldn’t work for every story but it fits Cat Girl just right.
The other story we get is the first episode of Ping-Pong Paula,this comes after an interview with Alison Fitt (nee Christie) and is fitting example of her work. I wonder if the story is set for a reprint, which would be another reason to print the first episode here to entice readers in, I would be happy to see a volume of this. The other feature we get is a piece on Giorgio Giorgetti, I had not realised he’d died young, so it was nice to read his son’s memories of his fathers work.
An excellent addition to Rebellion’s specials collection and I must also mention a gorgeous cover by Marguerite Sauvage.
I haven’t managed to get a copy of this yet, but the new stories sound interesting, and I like the look of the Cat Girl artwork. Very good also to have the Alison Fitt interview and the article on Giorgetti.
Although I see that this one was put in as an illustration of Alison Fitt’s work, I hope Rebellion won’t make a habit of republishing single episodes of stories from the original comics. It reminds me too much of the “Best of” reprint books that have been published for several girls’ titles, most of which treated the comics purely as retro nostalgia, and some of which were pretty patronising in tone. What none of them did was to reprint full serial stories, or give any real idea of what they were like. As a result they gave a distorted and quite inadequate idea of the range and quality of the comics they were supposed to be celebrating.
I’m sure Rebellion don’t want to replicate this kind of coverage for the original Jintys and Tammys, so I hope they will be cautious about publishing extracts from original serials. If a story is worth reprinting (and I think this one is, although it wouldn’t be top of my list), it’s worth reprinting in full.
Isn’t it tantalising, only single episodes reprinted and leaving us hungering to see the rest.
I wonder why they chose Paula for this reprint?
Glad they did as I wrote it, lol.
Ping-Pong Paula is a very good story. Quite a tale in how pride blinds people to the damage they can do to themselves and others.
Oh yes I wouldn’t like if the specials became all reprints, but the occasional one, surrounded by new stories would be fine. I think particularly if they are trying to decide on giving story a full reprint or want to highlight a certain creator.
I wonder rather than a full collection, they may consider doing more stories similar to how they released Janus Stark, which is more similar to the DCT Lucky Charm books.
If they reprint Somewhere over the Rainbow it would need its own volume at 36 episodes. Imagine if they reprint Merry at Misery House – 62 episodes.
It’s great to see Cat Girl return. She has been a most enduring character. I find it strange she didn’t last longer in Tammy than she did. But she appeared in Wee Sue’s retrospective in Tammy’s 10th birthday issue, so they didn’t forget her.
I’m still annoyed about that Spellbound digital edition only being available for a short time. I didn’t even see it. Is it going to be made available again, I wonder?
I don’t know, it does seem there was stuff going in the background, if it doesn’t appear around this Halloween instead, I feel very doubtful it would be released in the future.